TNews - The SWAP battery technology in electric vehicles has become a hot topic in the automotive world, particularly when examining the differing views of automotive experts in the West and Indonesia. In the West, there is a critical perspective on the use of SWAP battery technology, while in Indonesia, this technology is seen as a potential solution. In this article, we will explore the reasons behind these contrasting views.
Western Automotive Experts' Perspective: Critique of SWAP Battery Technology
Western automotive experts emphasize the physical aspect of electric vehicle batteries as a critical point in evaluating SWAP battery technology. The electric vehicle batteries, with weights ranging from 500 to 1,000 kg, are considered a major obstacle in implementing SWAP battery systems. This is due to the complexity and weight of the batteries that must be manually lifted and replaced. Establishing infrastructure capable of handling such heavy batteries is a challenging and potentially technically significant task.
The SWAP battery process requires infrastructure that is not only physically robust but also efficient in managing these heavy batteries. Considerations regarding the safety and reliability of lifting and replacing batteries become a primary focus, given that the weight of the batteries cannot be overlooked. Western automotive experts doubt whether this manual process can be executed efficiently without compromising user safety and comfort.
The physical constraints also raise serious questions about efficiency and user comfort. Electric vehicle users are expected to easily and quickly replace their batteries when needed, but the significant weight of the batteries can be a hindrance to daily usage. Considering ergonomic aspects and ease of use in SWAP battery technology becomes a crucial element in assessing whether this technology can be accepted by consumers.
In this context, Western automotive experts argue that the physical constraints of batteries are not only a technical issue but also have the potential to be a significant barrier to the adoption of SWAP battery technology. Mature thinking and innovative solutions are required to overcome these physical challenges for this technology to become a viable and acceptable option for the wider public.
The process of removing and replacing batteries in electric vehicles in the West is considered a significant challenge in implementing SWAP battery technology. This operation takes a considerable amount of time, ranging from 30 minutes to 1 hour, to extract the depleted battery and replace it with a new one. This time constraint is not only a problem for electric vehicle owners who must allocate extra time for this process but also a serious concern for battery replacement station operators.
Western automotive experts underline that the time constraint of removing and replacing batteries can affect the overall mobility of users. Electric vehicle users might be hindered in their daily activities due to this time-consuming process. Therefore, optimization and efficiency in the removal and replacement process are critical to minimize the negative impact on electric vehicle usage.
Furthermore, the financial aspect becomes a critical focus in evaluating SWAP battery technology. The cost of removing and replacing batteries, ranging from Rp1-2 million per process, is considered a potential financial burden for consumers. In the developing ecosystem of electric vehicles, such additional costs can be a serious barrier to achieving mass acceptance of electric vehicles.
Western automotive experts question the financial sustainability of this business model, given the competition with faster traditional charging models. Additional costs for the battery removal and replacement process can reduce the financial appeal of electric vehicles, which should ideally become more affordable and efficient in the long term. Therefore, emphasis on reducing operational costs, including the cost of battery removal and replacement, is essential in designing a sustainable and acceptable strategy for consumers in the Western market.
However, the more fundamental criticism from the Western perspective is the perception of SWAP battery technology as an inefficient solution. In Western countries, the electric charging infrastructure is already quite developed, reducing the need for SWAP batteries. This viewpoint arises from the belief that replacing batteries is not the optimal solution in a context where electric charging is easily accessible.
Indonesian Automotive Experts' Perspective: The Potential of SWAP Battery as a Solution
On the other side of the globe, Indonesian automotive experts view SWAP battery technology as a potential solution. The first factor emphasized is the inadequate condition of the electric charging infrastructure in Indonesia. Until the end of 2023, the number of Public Electric Vehicle Charging Stations (SPKLU) has only reached around 1,000 units, far from the ambitious government target.
The inadequacy of the electric charging infrastructure poses a serious obstacle to the growth of electric vehicles in Indonesia. SWAP batteries become an intriguing alternative as they overcome the infrastructure constraints, allowing consumers to use electric vehicles without being hindered by the availability of charging stations.
Additionally, the still relatively high prices of electric vehicles in Indonesia support the case for SWAP batteries. Electric vehicles are generally sold above Rp500 million, making them unaffordable for a large portion of the Indonesian population. With SWAP battery technology, consumers can have easier access without facing high initial costs.
Another advantage seen by Indonesian automotive experts is the environmental aspect. SWAP batteries are considered more environmentally friendly as they support the recycling of depleted batteries. Batteries that can no longer be used can be returned to the SWAP battery service provider for recycling, reducing the environmental impact of battery waste.
However, amid the optimism about SWAP battery technology, Indonesian automotive experts also acknowledge challenges. One of them is battery standardization. With various sizes and shapes of electric vehicle batteries, there needs to be an effort towards standardization for SWAP batteries to be universally applicable to all electric vehicle models.
Cost challenges are also a serious concern. The costs of removing and replacing batteries, as well as battery rental fees, need to be regulated to remain affordable for consumers. The sustainability of SWAP battery technology in Indonesia depends on its ability to address these challenges.
Meeting Perspectives and Future Expectations
Despite differing perspectives between Western and Indonesian automotive experts on SWAP battery technology, a meeting of minds could be the key to creating a holistic solution. The implementation of this technology in Indonesia may require adaptation to fit local infrastructure conditions and consumer needs.
A collaborative approach among stakeholders, including the government, car manufacturers, and SWAP battery service providers, can be a crucial step in formulating effective solutions. Battery standardization, cost control, and innovation in electric charging infrastructure are some aspects that need to be collectively considered.
In responding to the critical views from the West, Indonesia can leverage SWAP battery technology as an opportunity to lead innovation in the electric vehicle market. By overcoming infrastructure constraints and high prices, this technology can drive the growth of the electric vehicle industry in Indonesia while contributing positively to global efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
In facing the complexity of this issue, one thing is certain: open discussions and cross-border collaborations will be key to achieving sustainable and widely accepted solutions.